So, hope everyone had a great fourth of July, did something fun and all, maybe got accidentally burned by some illegal sparklers you set off. Anyhow, burnt or not, macaroni and cheese is still a staple here. Whether you're the type to go out and get the gooey orange stuff that takes less time to to make than look for a fork in the dishwasher to eat it with, I won't judge. There are times when that has solved my problems, I won't deny it. But this 4th of July, I think we hit the arguably best version on mac and cheese from scratch that we ever made. I'll try to estimate the amounts of ingredients we used as best I can, but it was pretty much throwing a lot of stuff in a pot and covering it for a while.
Mac and Cheese from Scratch
- 2 boxes (16 oz) elbow macaroni
- 1 onion
- 1 pkg cheddar cheese (8 oz) shredded
- 1 pkg monterey jack cheese (8 oz) shredded
- a little over 2 c milk
- 6 Tbs flour
- 1 tsp mustard powder
- salt/pepper to taste
- 1/2 pkg crackers
- (optional) herbs
- shortening (oil, butter, margarine, whatever you normally use) about 2 Tbs
Take the packages of cheese, and if you haven't already, go ahead and shred them. We did it by hand since they were in huge blocks to begin with.
Cheddar cheese is the classic go-to cheese for this recipe, and it's important, at least for this, to get good cheddar cheese. (Something like Velveeta or american singles will not do the same job.) If you like sharper cheddar, go for sharper, if less sharp, stay on the mild side.
What lots of people don't realize about mac and cheese is that it's not only cheddar cheese. Trust me, I've tried just cheddar before and it tastes really strong and not at all what you're idea of mac and cheese is. An equal amount of a mellower cheese is also important to balance out the cheddar. We used monterey jack, but any less strong cheese should work.
Then just fill a pot with water to boil on the stove. Once that's boiling, you'll add the pasta. Get another pot to start your sauce. The base for bechamels and also the sauce for this recipe is what's called a roux, which is just a fancy french name for what you're about to do. Chop the onion and add it to your shortening, sauteeing until the onions are soft and sort of colored.

There should be extra shortening even after the onions are done. If not just add a bit more, you'll need it for the next part. Add in the mustard powder and flour to the onions. After the flour is added, it'll look like a big bunch of dry, lumpy flour, but don't freak out cuz that's what you want it to look like. Slowly, a little bit at a time, start adding the milk into the mixture, smoothing out the flour with it until it comes together. Once you've added all the milk, keep stirring until it gets to a rolling boil. (Don't leave the stove though, or it'll boil over! Happened once to me, and the idea of me in the kitchen was never the same to anyone again.) If the water's boiling, it might be a good time to add in the pasta to the other pot. Cook the pasta for a minute or two less than directed, it'll cook more with the sauce. Once the milk reaches a boil, turn off the stove and dump in all of the shredded cheese. Keep mixing until it sort of melts in to form a sauce. Add salt and pepper to taste. Guess what? The sauce is done. Not kidding. I told you it was easy. Pasta should be done by this point, so drain and add to the sauce. That can sit for a while. I made breadcrumbs to put on mine since I have a thing with breadcrumbs. I used whatever salty-ish crackers were around, ground them up (food processor or mortar/pestle), chopped some herbs (thyme, oregano) and toasted them in olive oil before adding them on top of everything.
(Serves 6+)